Acrylic signs · specification comparison

xTool P2S vs. OMTech Maker 60W: what the specs can tell you

Both are CO₂ laser candidates for an acrylic sign workflow. The published power and work-area numbers are useful filters, but they cannot tell you which one makes a better finished sign in your shop.

Published September 30, 2026 · Manufacturer listings reviewed · No hands-on testing

Compare the published starting points

QuestionxTool P2SOMTech Maker MF1624-60
Laser typeCO₂CO₂
Manufacturer-stated power55W60W
Manufacturer-stated work area600 × 305 mm (about 23.6 × 12.0 in)16 × 24 in (also listed as 400 × 600 mm)
Source checked on2026-09-302026-09-30
Check before orderingUsable area for your actual sheet and fixture; extraction, cooling, electrical setup, software, support, delivery, and total installed cost.

The dimensions and power above are manufacturer statements checked on September 30, 2026. They are not measurements by MakerSpec Lab. Product configurations and listings can change.

Why a 5W difference does not settle it

Published rated power does not establish edge quality, throughput, or the cost of a sellable sign. Ask each vendor to cut the same sheet from your supplier at your intended thickness, using the same artwork and acceptance criteria. Request the configuration and settings used, then compare the finished edges and time for a complete batch.

Estimate your sales, operator hours and setup recovery

Send this sample brief to both vendors

  1. Exact acrylic supplier, grade, color, thickness, and protective film.
  2. Largest stock sheet and finished sign dimensions, including small text or fine details.
  3. Batch size, acceptable edge finish, reject criteria, and target time per sellable sign.
  4. Workspace dimensions, exhaust route, electrical availability, and operator plan.
  5. Written quote for the complete required configuration, consumables, service, warranty, and returns.

Review current manufacturer listings

These direct links carry no affiliate tracking. They are provided for current specifications and vendor contact, not as an endorsement.

For material compatibility, also check the xTool selection guide and the OMTech CO₂ safety instructions. Assess the complete installation with qualified local help before operation.

No hands-on comparison or ranked recommendation is claimed. See the link disclosure above for the current status.